- lsktravelz@gmail.com
Years ago, I booked through Southwest Hotels and scored a good deal on Rapid Rewards points. Fast forward to 2026. I have another opportunity to book. Let’s examine my 3-night hotel reservation in Atlanta, Georgia. Should I book through Southwest Hotels or book directly with my preferred loyalty brand (Hilton)? Many travelers face this question when trying to maximize rewards.
To maximize this deal, you must be a Rapid Rewards Member, though you can join immediately before booking. Keep in mind that the highest point bonuses are reserved for A-List Preferred members (40+ flights). If you hold standard A-List status (20 flights), you will likely earn at the base member rate.
For this specific stay, the cost is $513 (including fees). Depending on your status, you would earn:
As a Hilton Honors Diamond Member, booking directly costs $625. However, your status significantly boosts your return. You would earn approximately 19,375 Hilton Honors points (10 base points per $1, plus a 100% Diamond bonus), averaging out to roughly 31 points per dollar spent.
The choice hinges on which currency you value more. By choosing Southwest Hotels, you save $112 upfront and earn at least 7,700 Rapid Rewards points (roughly equivalent to $100 in airfare value).
However, booking through a third-party portal like Southwest usually means Hilton will not recognize your Diamond status. You would likely forfeit:
Pro Tip: If you apply a Free Night Award, your Hilton cash cost drops to $395 while still netting you 14,306 points—making the direct booking the undisputed winner.
If you don’t have high-tier hotel status, the $112 cash savings and airline points make Southwest Hotels the clear winner. However, for a Diamond member, the $108 F&B credit plus the value of Hilton points effectively erases the Southwest discount. When you factor in potential room upgrades, the “cost” of loyalty actually breaks even.
What did I do? I used a free award night and split the cost of the reservation with a friend traveling with me. Even though my cost should have been $197, I received a $200 Hilton Aspire credit. That happens occasionally when I forget about a benefit, and I still earned 14,306 Hilton Honors points. I will stick to earning Rapid Rewards through flights. Weigh the cash saved against loyalty perks to make the best decision for your travel style.